AI VORTEXLEGAL AI RISK
AI visibilityConsultingSearch free
Public trackerCorpus refreshed Oct 4, 2026 · Latest decision Oct 1, 2026Public incidents are risk signals, not usage-adjusted rates
HomeCasesGarciduenas v. Matrix New World Engineering, Inc.
Evidence-linked corpus record: this page is generated from the structured public record and has a publication-readiness score of 81/100. It is publicly indexable with its documented evidence gaps stated on-page; the linked source and evidence boundary remain controlling.
Corpus matter record

Garciduenas v. Matrix New World Engineering, Inc.

CA Arizona (1d) · Jul 23, 2026

AZ / stateEditorial impact: lowfake citationsfabricated quotestortappellateWarning
Direct answer

What happened in this matter?

Fabricated: Case Law | The original consolidated reply brief contained 14 incorrect reporter citations. The court identified these as citation errors but did not find that the cited cases were nonexistent. Outcome: Admonishment.

Why the court cared
The structured public record identifies fake citations and fabricated quotes and records Admonishment. The linked source controls the precise reasoning and procedural context.
Why it matters now
This matter connects fake citations and fabricated quotes with Admonishment in CA Arizona (1d). It provides a source-linked baseline for verification, supervision, and response controls.

Why this matter is tracked

Fabricated: Case Law | The original consolidated reply brief contained 14 incorrect reporter citations. The court identified these as citation errors but did not find that the cited cases were nonexistent. Outcome: Admonishment.

Operational lesson

This matter connects fake citations and fabricated quotes with Admonishment in CA Arizona (1d). It provides a source-linked baseline for verification, supervision, and response controls.

Record details

ArizonaSingle-state evidence scope
Explore AZOpen its source-linked jurisdiction page and related matters.
CourtCA Arizona (1d)
Jurisdictionstate
Circuit9th Circuit
DateJul 23, 2026
AI
AI toolAI (implied, unspecified)
Party typeLawyer
OutcomeAdmonishment
Known amountNot recorded
Professional sanctionNo
Attribution boundary

What the record establishes about AI use

reported

AI (implied, unspecified) is recorded in the source dataset; confirm the basis in the linked document.

Procedural posture

Admonishment

Correction behavior

Correction behavior is not separately verified in the current record.

Tracked discrepancy record

4 citation, quotation, or authority issues are recorded in the source dataset.

  1. Fabricated: Case Law | The original consolidated reply brief contained 14 incorrect reporter citations. The court identified these as citation errors but did not find that the cited cases were nonexistent.
  2. False Quotes: Case Law | The original consolidated reply brief included 20 quotations that did not appear in the cited cases, including five quotations inconsistent with the cited authorities.
  3. Fabricated: Case Law | The amended consolidated reply brief still contained 14 incorrect reporter citations.
  4. False Quotes: Case Law | The amended consolidated reply brief still contained 13 misquoted authorities, although the court stated the cited cases generally supported the propositions offered.

Questions this record answers

What happened in Garciduenas v. Matrix New World Engineering, Inc.?
Fabricated: Case Law | The original consolidated reply brief contained 14 incorrect reporter citations. The court identified these as citation errors but did not find that the cited cases were nonexistent. Outcome: Admonishment.
Why does Garciduenas v. Matrix New World Engineering, Inc. matter for legal AI risk?
This matter connects fake citations and fabricated quotes with Admonishment in CA Arizona (1d). It provides a source-linked baseline for verification, supervision, and response controls.
What does the public record establish about Garciduenas v. Matrix New World Engineering, Inc.?
The record summarizes the outcome described in the linked public source. The recorded document is hosted in the upstream publisher archive. This page is not a substitute for the complete docket, subsequent history, or jurisdiction-specific advice.
Which source supports this Garciduenas v. Matrix New World Engineering, Inc. summary?
The recorded source is Damien Charlotin case archive. It is classified as publisher document archive; review the linked material and subsequent docket history before relying on this summary.

Related matters

Related by court, jurisdiction, tool, or classified failure pattern. Similarity does not imply the same facts or outcome.

Varela v. HauserCA Arizona (1d) · Sep 17, 2026same court · fake citations + fabricated quotesWRI Summit REIT LP v. KuerschnerCA Arizona (1d) · Aug 10, 2026same court · fake citations + fabricated quotesNgaruiya v. GillCA Arizona (1d) · Jun 16, 2026same court · fake citations + fabricated quotesFHMC, LLC et al. v. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Arizona, Inc.CA Arizona (1d) · Jun 22, 2026same court · fake citations + appellateHampton v. LoftonCA Arizona (1d) · Mar 31, 2026same court · fake citations + appellateDineen/Shibata v. KotchkaCA Arizona (1d) · Jul 15, 2026same court · fake citations + appellate