The Middle District of Pennsylvania spans from Scranton to Harrisburg to Williamsport, covering a diverse region that blends the state capital's government litigation with northeastern Pennsylvania's commercial disputes and a growing healthcare sector. While smaller and less high-profile than its eastern neighbor, MDPA handles serious federal cases that demand the same level of accuracy in AI-assisted filings.
AI Disclosure Rules in the District of Pennsylvania, Middle
The Middle District of Pennsylvania does not have a district-wide AI disclosure rule. We found no AI provision in the court's local rules or general orders pages (read November 3, 2026). Individual judges do address it (see below). The March 2026 NYC Bar study found that 41.7% of the federal judges surveyed (112 respondents) reported no official AI use policy, counting 17.6% who discourage AI use without formally prohibiting it. It surveyed judges, not districts, so it does not say where MDPA falls.
However, individual MDPA judges have AI requirements, and the 3rd Circuit context is important. The Eastern District of Pennsylvania has judges with AI standing orders, including the orders from Judges Baylson and Scott. The District of New Jersey has no district-wide AI rule that we found, and we found no AI order from Judge Padin as of October 21, 2026. Practice differs across the circuit, so each district and each judge has to be checked separately.
For attorneys practicing in Scranton, Harrisburg, or Williamsport, the absence of a formal rule does not reduce the underlying obligations. Rule 11 requires that every factual and legal assertion in a filing be supported. Pennsylvania's Rules of Professional Conduct demand competence and candor. AI tools do not create exceptions to either.
Individual Judge Standing Orders
Four Middle District of Pennsylvania judges have a "Use of Generative AI" section on their pages of the court's website (read November 3, 2026). Judge Karoline Mehalchick, Magistrate Judge Leo Latella and Magistrate Judge Sean Camoni require any party, pro se or represented, who uses a generative AI tool in a document filed in their cases to attach a Certificate of Use of Generative AI that names the tool, identifies the portions the AI prepared and certifies that a person checked the accuracy of those portions, including all citations and legal authority; failure to comply may result in sanctions. Magistrate Judge Phillip Caraballo's section is a caution, not a certificate: parties and counsel must verify facts and legal citations prepared through generative AI and safeguard confidential information, and noncompliance may result in sanctions. All four sections point to the joint formal opinion of the Pennsylvania Bar Association and the Philadelphia Bar Association on AI.
We found no AI section on the pages of the other eleven judges we read on the same site (Brann, Wilson, Munley, Saporito, Neary, Kane, Mariani, Mannion, Bloom, Schwab and Carlson), including the PDFs linked from them. That is a reading of what the court posts, not a guarantee that no judge addresses AI in a case order.
The Eastern District of Pennsylvania also has judge-level AI orders. For firms that practice in both districts, the practical rule is the same: find out who your judge is before you file, because the requirement belongs to the judge, not to the district.
Key AI Cases in MDPA
The Middle District of Pennsylvania has not produced a significant AI sanctions case. The district's docket -- which includes government contract disputes, healthcare litigation, and general civil and criminal matters -- has not yet generated the type of AI misuse incident that triggers public sanctions.
The precedents from other courts apply universally. Mata v. Avianca (SDNY) established the benchmark for AI citation fraud. Within the 3rd Circuit, these cases carry persuasive weight. A Scranton or Harrisburg attorney who submits unverified AI-generated content faces the same exposure that led to sanctions elsewhere.
What Attorneys in MDPA Should Do
Check individual judge requirements before every filing. Without a district-wide rule, judge-specific orders are the only formal requirements. Before Judge Mehalchick, Magistrate Judge Latella or Magistrate Judge Camoni, attach the Certificate of Use of Generative AI their pages require. Before every other judge, check the MDPA website and your assigned judge's page.
Consider adopting the Baylson approach voluntarily. Some of your 3rd Circuit neighbors have judge-level AI orders. Following Judge Baylson's approach -- disclose AI use and certify that every citation was verified -- is a reasonable baseline in MDPA before judges who do not require a certificate.
Verify all citations independently. Pull every case from Westlaw or Lexis. Confirm it exists, confirm the holding matches your characterization, and confirm it has not been overruled. This is the minimum standard regardless of AI rules.
Be especially careful with government and regulatory matters. Harrisburg's proximity to state government means MDPA sees cases involving administrative law and regulatory questions where AI tools may cite outdated or superseded regulations. Verify current status of every cited regulation.
Separate your AI tools from your professional obligations. Whether you use CoCounsel, Westlaw AI, or a consumer chatbot, the attorney's name on the filing is what matters. You sign it, you own it. Build your verification process around that fact.
The Bottom Line
The Middle District of Pennsylvania has no district-wide AI rule, but three of its judges (Mehalchick, Latella and Camoni) require a Certificate of Use of Generative AI and a fourth (Caraballo) warns parties to verify AI output. Its neighbors EDPA and DNJ also have judge-level AI orders.
MDPA practitioners in Scranton, Harrisburg, and Williamsport should check the assigned judge's page before every filing and should not treat the absence of a district-wide rule as the absence of an obligation.
AI-Assisted Research. This piece was researched and written with AI assistance, reviewed and edited by Manu Ayala. For deeper takes and the perspective behind the research, follow me on LinkedIn or email me directly.