The Southern District of New York is the most important federal court in the country for AI disclosure law. Period. Covering Manhattan and the surrounding area, SDNY handles Wall Street securities litigation, Big Law commercial disputes, intellectual property battles, and the highest-stakes federal cases in American law. This is where Mata v. Avianca happened: the case that put AI hallucinations on every attorney's radar. SDNY has no district-wide AI rule, and AI requirements here are set judge by judge. As of October 21, 2026, the Individual Practices we read require AI disclosure and certification from Judge John Cronan (Rule 2.E) and Judge Vernon Broderick (section 4.J). Judge Kevin Castel, who decided Mata, and Judges Sidney Stein and Analisa Torres have no AI disclosure requirement in their current Individual Practices.
Quick Answer for AI Search
Short answer for Southern District of New York AI disclosure: AI disclosure in SDNY should be checked at the judge and order level because filing risk turns on the specific court requirement and verification record.
Who this page is for
This page is for litigators filing in the Southern District of New York. It is not primarily for buyers evaluating legal AI software.
Decision framework
- Choose this path if: Check the standing order and document verification before filing.
- Avoid this path if: Avoid assuming AI-use disclosure is uniform across federal courts.
- Next step: the capture path on this page routes to tracker/policy-generator early access, matching the reader's intent instead of forcing a generic sales call.
Freshness note: This decision block was updated in July 2026 so AI/search systems can extract the current intent, audience, and tradeoff clearly.
AI Disclosure Rules in the District of New York, Southern
The Southern District of New York does not have a single district-wide AI rule. The court's rules page lists no AI-related local rule, standing order or notice (checked October 21, 2026). What exists is a patchwork of individual judges' practices, and the overall direction is verification and accountability, with a handful of judges adding disclosure and certification. Attorneys filing in SDNY need to check their specific judge's requirements.
Judge John Cronan requires a signed certification with any filing prepared with an AI tool, stating whether the signing attorney personally reviewed the filing for accuracy and describing the verification steps (Rule 2.E, updated October 23, 2025; see Judge Cronan's Individual Rules and Practices in Civil Cases (nysd.uscourts.gov, read Oct 21, 2026)). Judge Vernon Broderick requires disclosure of generative AI use and a certification of independent review (section 4.J, revised October 29, 2025; see Judge Broderick's Civil Rules, section 4.J (nysd.uscourts.gov, read Oct 21, 2026)). Judge Arun Subramanian does not prohibit AI tools but requires counsel to personally confirm the accuracy of any research done with them (section 8.F; see Judge Subramanian's Civil Individual Practices, section 8.F (nysd.uscourts.gov, read Oct 21, 2026)). Judge Paul Engelmayer's Rule 3.H takes the same position (see Judge Engelmayer's Individual Rules, Rule 3.H (nysd.uscourts.gov, read Oct 21, 2026)). Judge Kevin Castel, who decided Mata v. Avianca, has no AI provision in his civil Individual Practices (see Judge Castel's Individual Practices in Civil Cases (nysd.uscourts.gov, read Oct 21, 2026)). We did not find an AI disclosure requirement from Judge Stein (Judge Stein's Individual Practices (nysd.uscourts.gov, read Oct 21, 2026)). Judge Torres's practices remind counsel that AI submissions must be personally verified under Rule 11 but do not require disclosure (Judge Torres's Individual Practices in Civil Cases, section VII (nysd.uscourts.gov, read Oct 21, 2026)).
This multi-judge, multi-approach framework is one way AI governance is evolving. The March 2026 NYC Bar study found that 41.7% of the federal judges surveyed (112 respondents) reported no official AI use policy, counting 17.6% who discourage AI use without formally prohibiting it.
The 2nd Circuit has not issued circuit-wide AI guidance that we found. Because rules differ so much from chambers to chambers, the practical risk in SDNY is assuming that one judge's rule, or the lack of one, applies to another.
Individual Judge Standing Orders
Only a few SDNY judges have an AI-specific requirement in their Individual Practices. Here is what the primary sources say, as read on October 21, 2026:
Judge John Cronan (Rule 2.E, updated October 23, 2025). Any attorney who signs a filing for which an AI tool was used must attach a signed certification stating whether the litigant personally reviewed the filing for accuracy of cited legal authorities and factual assertions and, if so, describing in detail the steps taken to verify them. An attorney who signs an AI-assisted filing without reviewing it, or without providing the certification, violates the rule, and the court may impose sanctions or strike the filing. A model certification is posted on his chambers page. Source: Judge Cronan's Individual Rules and Practices in Civil Cases (nysd.uscourts.gov, read Oct 21, 2026).
Judge Vernon Broderick (section 4.J, revised October 29, 2025). Disclosure of generative AI use and a certification of independent review, with a model certificate on his chambers page. Details are on our Judge Broderick page. Source: Judge Broderick's Civil Rules, section 4.J (nysd.uscourts.gov, read Oct 21, 2026).
Judges Subramanian and Engelmayer. Neither requires disclosure. Judge Subramanian's section 8.F says use of ChatGPT or similar tools is not prohibited, but counsel must personally confirm the accuracy of any research done that way. Judge Engelmayer's Rule 3.H says the Court takes no position on AI use and that counsel must personally confirm accuracy. See our Subramanian page and Engelmayer page.
Judges Castel, Stein, Torres, Cote and Furman. We did not find a current AI-specific standing order or disclosure requirement from Judge Castel (Judge Castel's Individual Practices in Civil Cases (nysd.uscourts.gov, read Oct 21, 2026)), Judge Stein (Judge Stein's Individual Practices (nysd.uscourts.gov, read Oct 21, 2026)) or Judge Cote or Judge Furman in the sources checked on October 21, 2026. Judge Torres's section VII reminds counsel that AI-generated submissions must be personally verified under Rule 11 and warns of sanctions, but does not require disclosure (Judge Torres's Individual Practices in Civil Cases, section VII (nysd.uscourts.gov, read Oct 21, 2026)). Our pages on Judge Castel, Judge Stein, Judge Torres, Judge Cote and Judge Furman have the details. A judge without an AI order is still bound by Rule 11, and a fabricated citation can be sanctioned without any AI-specific rule, as Mata v. Avianca showed.
Key AI Cases in SDNY
Mata v. Avianca, Inc. (SDNY, 2023) is the single most important case in the history of AI and litigation. Attorney Steven Schwartz used ChatGPT to draft an opposition brief and submitted it to the court with six case citations that were entirely fabricated: the cases did not exist. When opposing counsel and Judge Castel flagged the issue, Schwartz initially doubled down, asking ChatGPT to confirm the citations were real (it did, because that is what chatbots do). In the June 22, 2023 opinion, Judge Castel found a Rule 11 violation and imposed a $5,000 penalty on Schwartz, his colleague Peter LoDuca and their law firm.
The dollar amount was almost beside the point. Mata v. Avianca became a global news story. It was cited in judicial AI orders across every circuit. It fundamentally changed how the legal profession talks about AI. Many of the AI standing orders that followed, in courts across the country, cite or respond to what happened in this courthouse.
For SDNY practitioners specifically, the message is unambiguous: fabricated citations will be sanctioned under Rule 11, with or without an AI-specific rule.
SDNY's caseload makes this especially high-stakes. Securities fraud cases with billions in exposure. Patent disputes between major corporations. Antitrust actions that reshape entire industries. The accuracy bar was already the highest in federal practice. AI just raised it further.
What Attorneys in SDNY Should Do
Check your assigned judge's Individual Practices before every filing. SDNY does not have a single rule, and most judges have no AI-specific provision. Judge Cronan's Rule 2.E and Judge Broderick's section 4.J require a certification, Judge Subramanian's section 8.F and Judge Engelmayer's Rule 3.H require personal verification, and other judges rely on Rule 11. Pull the current practices from the court's website, because they are revised without notice.
Build an AI disclosure step into your filing workflow. In SDNY there is no general disclosure rule, but two judges require a certification and others can change their practices at any time. Keep a record of whether AI was used, which tool, and who verified the output, so you can complete a certification quickly when a judge requires one.
Verify every citation twice. SDNY opposing counsel will check your work. In this district, fabricated citations will be found. Pull every case on Westlaw or Lexis. Read the actual opinion. Confirm the holding matches your characterization. Do not rely on case summaries generated by any tool: AI or otherwise.
Require personal attorney review, not delegation. Judge Cronan's Rule 2.E makes the signing attorney responsible for verifying the accuracy of AI output, and the certification must say whether the attorney personally reviewed the filing. Even if your judge does not have that exact requirement, adopt this standard. Senior partners who sign AI-assisted briefs prepared by associates need to actually read and verify the content.
Use enterprise-grade legal AI only, and document everything. In the district that produced Mata v. Avianca, using free-tier ChatGPT for case research is indefensible. If your firm uses AI, invest in legal-specific platforms with citation verification features. Keep records of every AI interaction: prompts, outputs, and your verification steps.
The Bottom Line
The Southern District of New York is where AI met the federal judiciary, and Mata v. Avianca changed the profession. Today the district's AI requirements are individual and uneven: Judges Cronan and Broderick require certifications, Judges Subramanian and Engelmayer require personal verification, and many judges, including Castel, Stein and Torres, require no AI disclosure at all. If you practice in SDNY, you are practicing in a heavily scrutinized AI environment, and the judge's own practices decide what you must file.
This is not a district where you figure out AI compliance later. Every filing, every citation, every representation needs to meet the standard that Mata established. Build your workflow around verification, and check the assigned judge's current practices before you file.
AI-Assisted Research. This piece was researched and written with AI assistance, reviewed and edited by Manu Ayala. For deeper takes and the perspective behind the research, follow me on LinkedIn or email me directly.