This guide covers what the data shows, how courts have responded in recent decisions, and what a self-represented party should do before filing. Every case below links to the written decision or to its tracker entry. The underlying database is Damien Charlotin's AI Hallucination Cases Database, and we credit it for the case collection.

What the data shows

The counts below come from the tracker dataset at aivortex.io/legal-ai-risk, which is built on the Charlotin database. The snapshot has 2,223 decisions dated through October 23, 2026. A decision counts as pro se when the tracker carries its `pro-se` tag, the label for self-represented parties.

MeasureCount in the dataset (read October 28, 2026)
All decisions2,223
Decisions tagged pro se1,280
US decisions1,510
US decisions tagged pro se901
Pro se decisions dated 20239
Pro se decisions dated 202434
Pro se decisions dated 2025478
Pro se decisions dated 2026 (to October 23)759

Two cautions. The database grows as people find and submit decisions, so recent months are still filling in and the yearly counts are not an incidence rate. And the tag reflects how the decision was classified, not a count of everyone who ever filed an AI-generated citation. Our statistics page explains how we read the dataset.

For the current month, the tracker's October 2026 statistics split new decisions by party type and jurisdiction.

What courts did to pro se filers

Each decision in the tracker has one or more outcome labels. Among the 1,280 pro se decisions, the labels break down like this. A decision can carry more than one label, so the rows add up to more than 1,280.

Outcome labelPro se decisions
Warning523
None adjudicated (the corpus label for decisions without a ruling on sanctions)480
Monetary (costs or a fine)145
Case or appeal dismissed89
Filing or brief struck58
Order to show cause33

A warning is the most common result. That fits the pattern in the cases below: courts often explain the problem, say that Rule 11 or its state equivalent applies, and hold the harsher step in reserve for the next filing.

Why "I'm not a lawyer" doesn't help

Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 11 applies to "an attorney or unrepresented party" who signs a filing, and it requires that the legal contentions be warranted by existing law. You can read the rule text at Cornell's Legal Information Institute. Courts do give self-represented parties some leeway on form and procedure. The recent decisions below show that the leeway stops at citations that don't exist.

The practical point is that the person who signs answers for the citation. The tool that produced it does not.

Recent pro se cases

These are eight of the decisions listed in the tracker with October 2026 dates, selected when this page was written on October 21, 2026 (decisions dated through October 15 at that time). The links go to the written decision hosted by the Charlotin database and to the tracker entry. Where we've written a summary, it's linked too. The outcome column is the tracker's label for the result.

CaseCourtOutcome labelDecisionTracker
Waushara County v. BruningWisconsin Court of AppealsWarningOpinion (PDF)Entry
Davis v. Tressler and YorkIndiana Court of AppealsAdverse costs orderOpinion (PDF)Entry
Sabatini v. Pennsylvania PUCPennsylvania Commonwealth CourtWarningOpinion (PDF)Entry
King v. AT&T Corp.W.D. WashingtonCertification requirementOrder (PDF)Entry
Thornton v. Amazon.com ServicesE.D. CaliforniaWarningOrder (PDF)Entry
Deen v. VMKCalifornia Court of Appeal (6th Dist.)No sanction labeledOpinion (PDF)Entry
U.S. Bank v. ThomasHawaii Intermediate Court of AppealsRule violation found, no sanctionsOpinion (PDF)Entry
Cox v. MitchellFifth CircuitNo sanction labeledOpinion (PDF)Entry

What the recent cases show

Our own summaries of these decisions, each linked above, point to a few patterns.

  • The first response is usually a warning. In Waushara County, the Wisconsin Court of Appeals found nonexistent and unrelated citations in a traffic appeal, declined to sanction, and warned about generative AI. Sabatini and Thornton ended the same way: a warning, not a penalty.
  • Costs come when the problem persists. In Davis, the Indiana Court of Appeals found that the briefs rested on nonexistent cases and miscited law, and remanded to set appellate fees against the self-represented appellant.
  • Some courts add a process requirement. In King v. AT&T, the judge found Rule 11 violations, skipped fees and dismissal, and ordered a sworn certification about AI use on every filing.
  • A bad citation can lose the argument even without a sanction. In Deen, the court flagged a nonexistent case, rejected the argument that relied on it, and affirmed.

None of this is a forecast. Each judge decides on the facts, and the tracker labels are a summary, so read the decision itself before you rely on any of it.

Where Mata v. Avianca fits

Mata v. Avianca is the 2023 case most people cite first, and it involved lawyers, not self-represented parties. It matters here because it set the template: a court found citations to cases that didn't exist and put the signer's duty to check at the center. The pro se decisions apply the same logic to people without a license. The Mata page now carries a short list of the recent pro se decisions as well.

A pre-filing check for self-represented parties

If you're filing without a lawyer and you used any AI tool to find or write citations, this is the minimum.

  1. Open every case in a primary source. Use the court's own website, a government site or a free case law database. If you can't find the case there, don't cite it.
  2. Read the part you cite. A real case can still say something different from your sentence. Find the passage and compare.
  3. Check every quotation word for word. Altered or invented quotes get flagged separately from invented cases.
  4. Write down what you checked. A short list with the date and source for each cite is enough, and our citation verification log gives a format.
  5. Read your court's rules on AI. Some courts require a disclosure or a certification. What courts require on AI disclosure lists examples, and the rule in your court can differ.
  6. If you find a bad citation after filing, fix it quickly. Tell the court and the other side and withdraw or correct the filing. Mata shows that delay made the outcome worse.

For a longer walk-through, see how to verify AI legal citations and what happens if AI hallucinates in a court filing.

Sources

Questions and answers

What does pro se mean?

Pro se is Latin for "for oneself." A pro se litigant represents themselves in court without a lawyer.

Can a pro se litigant be sanctioned for AI-generated fake citations?

Yes. Federal Rule 11 applies to an unrepresented party who signs a filing, and the tracker lists hundreds of pro se decisions with outcomes such as warnings, costs, struck filings and dismissed appeals. What a court does in a given case depends on the judge and the facts.

How many pro se cases involve AI hallucinations?

In the tracker dataset we read on October 28, 2026, 1,280 of 2,223 decisions carry a pro se tag, and 901 of 1,510 US decisions do. The database keeps growing, so treat the counts as a snapshot.

Are courts harsher on lawyers than on self-represented parties?

We haven't measured that. The tracker shows many pro se decisions ending in a warning, and it also shows lawyers sanctioned. Seniority, repeat conduct and how the court was told about the problem all vary by case, so we don't draw a comparison from these counts.

Is it safe to use ChatGPT to write a court filing without a lawyer?

Using AI isn't what the decisions penalize. Citing authority that doesn't exist or doesn't say what you claim is. If you use any AI tool, verify each citation in a primary source before filing, and check your court's rules on AI use.

Operational information, not legal advice. Counts are a snapshot of the tracker dataset read October 28, 2026 (decisions dated through October 23, 2026); the database keeps growing. Case descriptions follow the linked decisions and our case summaries; read the decision itself before relying on one.

Next reads