Thomas Dexter Jakes v. Duane Youngblood
Record source: imported from Damien Charlotin’s AI Hallucination Cases Database (CC BY 4.0), which credits CourtListener (court record); linked document: storage.courtlistener.com. What AI Vortex adds.
W.D. Pennsylvania · Oct 6, 2025
What happened in this matter?
In Jakes v. Youngblood (W.D. Pa.), the court sanctioned Tyrone Blackburn, counsel for the defendant, under Rule 11 after briefs he filed were found to contain inaccurate citations and quotations, including inaccurate quotations from the court's own earlier opinion (show-cause order ECF No. 53, 26 June 2025). At the 24 July 2025 show-cause hearing he admitted the citation issues were caused by his use of generative AI to draft the briefs. The Memorandum Order of 6 October 2025 (ECF No. 71) imposes a $5,000 sanction, awarded to plaintiff's counsel as attorneys' fees and payable in monthly installments of not less than $500, and revokes his pro hac vice status.
- Why the court cared
- The court found that "monetary sanctions are necessary to deter Blackburn from future misconduct", especially because of his decision to "double-down" on his misuse of AI after it was brought to the court's attention, and that the amount sought by plaintiff was not a reasonable measure of a sanction. It revoked his pro hac vice status "due to his misconduct and violations of court rules" (ECF No. 71, pp. 5-6).
- Why it matters now
- Fabricated quotes ending in pro hac vice revocation — verify every quotation character-for-character against the source opinion.
Why this matter is tracked
In Jakes v. Youngblood (W.D. Pa.), the court sanctioned Tyrone Blackburn, counsel for the defendant, under Rule 11 after briefs he filed were found to contain inaccurate citations and quotations, including inaccurate quotations from the court's own earlier opinion (show-cause order ECF No. 53, 26 June 2025). At the 24 July 2025 show-cause hearing he admitted the citation issues were caused by his use of generative AI to draft the briefs. The Memorandum Order of 6 October 2025 (ECF No. 71) imposes a $5,000 sanction, awarded to plaintiff's counsel as attorneys' fees and payable in monthly installments of not less than $500, and revokes his pro hac vice status.
Fabricated quotes ending in pro hac vice revocation — verify every quotation character-for-character against the source opinion.
Record details
Corrected 2026-10-31: see the corrections log.
What the record establishes about AI use
Blackburn "admitted that the citation issues highlighted by the Memo Order were caused by his use of generative artificial intelligence (\"AI\") to draft his briefs"; the order does not name a tool.
Monetary Sanction; Pro Hac Vice status revoked
Correction behavior is not separately verified in the current record.
Tracked discrepancy record
10 citation, quotation, or authority issues are recorded in the source dataset.
- False Quotes: Exhibits & Submissions | Fabricated quotation attributed to the Court's April 25, 2025 Memorandum Opinion; Court found no such language in its opinion.
- False Quotes: Case Law | Fabricated quote attributed to Franklin Prescriptions, Inc. v. N.Y. Times Co.; Court found the quoted language does not exist in that opinion as cited.
- False Quotes: Case Law | Fabricated statement attributed to Franklin Prescriptions requiring pleading 'the exact words spoken or published'; Court found no such direct quotation in the cited authority.
- False Quotes: Case Law | Fabricated quotation purporting to be from Blackwell v. Eskin (Pa. Super. Ct. 2007); Court found the quoted language does not exist as presented.
- False Quotes: Case Law | Fabricated attribution claiming the Court 'noted that when the underlying tort collapses, there can be no cause of action for conspiracy' citing Hill v. Cosby; Court found the phrasing was not in the cited source.
- False Quotes: Case Law | Fabricated quotation attributed to Romano v. Young (E.D. Pa. 2011) claiming a specific holding about conspiracy pleadings; Court found the specific quoted language absent from that decision.
- False Quotes: Case Law | Fabricated quotation attributed to Duffy v. Lawyers Title Ins. Co. about group pleading in conspiracy claims; Court determined the quoted passage was not in the cited opinion as presented.
- False Quotes: Case Law | Multiple fabricated or partly fabricated quotations in the reply brief (e.g., Kurowski, Livingston, Moses, St. Amant) that the Court found do not exist in the cited authorities as quoted.
Show 2 additional discrepancies
- False Quotes: Case Law | Reply brief quotation claiming Pennsylvania courts 'have shown a willingness to interpret relatively mild statements as being capable of a defamatory meaning' attributed to Livingston v. Murray; Court found the quoted wording was fabricated.
- Misrepresented: Case Law | Misrepresentation: citing cases for propositions they do not support; Court noted multiple instances where Blackbum used cases for propositions the cases do not represent.
Questions this record answers
- What happened in Thomas Dexter Jakes v. Duane Youngblood?
- In Jakes v. Youngblood (W.D. Pa.), the court sanctioned Tyrone Blackburn, counsel for the defendant, under Rule 11 after briefs he filed were found to contain inaccurate citations and quotations, including inaccurate quotations from the court's own earlier opinion (show-cause order ECF No. 53, 26 June 2025). At the 24 July 2025 show-cause hearing he admitted the citation issues were caused by his use of generative AI to draft the briefs. The Memorandum Order of 6 October 2025 (ECF No. 71) imposes a $5,000 sanction, awarded to plaintiff's counsel as attorneys' fees and payable in monthly installments of not less than $500, and revokes his pro hac vice status.
- Why does Thomas Dexter Jakes v. Duane Youngblood matter for legal AI risk?
- Fabricated quotes ending in pro hac vice revocation — verify every quotation character-for-character against the source opinion.
- What does the public record establish about Thomas Dexter Jakes v. Duane Youngblood?
- Based on the Memorandum Order, ECF No. 71 (W.D. Pa., filed 6 October 2025), read in full from the CourtListener RECAP PDF. Later docket activity was not checked. This page is not a substitute for the complete docket, subsequent history, or jurisdiction-specific advice.
- Which source supports this Thomas Dexter Jakes v. Duane Youngblood summary?
- The recorded source is CourtListener / RECAP. It is classified as docket or legal-document mirror; review the linked material and subsequent docket history before relying on this summary.
Weekly alert: new AI-hallucination court cases
One short email a week with the newly recorded cases, courts and sanctions. Free, no spam, unsubscribe anytime.