Direct answer · as of November 6, 2026

The Garante's EUR 15 million fine against OpenAI (announced December 20, 2024) no longer stands as issued: the Garante's own page says Decision No. 755 of November 2, 2024 was temporarily removed from its website following judgment No. 4153/2026 of the Court of Rome, published March 18, 2026, which accepted the opposition to the decision. We have not read the judgment, so we do not state its grounds. Source: Garante press release on ChatGPT, read November 6, 2026.

Italy became the first country to ban ChatGPT and later fined OpenAI EUR 15 million (a fine a Rome court has since set aside). This case set the tone for European AI regulation and forced every AI company operating in the EU to rethink data practices. Attorneys advising companies with European users need to understand what happened here.


Background

On March 30, 2023, the Italian Data Protection Authority (Garante per la Protezione dei Dati Personali) issued an emergency order temporarily banning ChatGPT in Italy. The Garante cited multiple GDPR violations: OpenAI had no lawful basis for processing the personal data of Italian users, it failed to implement age verification to prevent minors from accessing the service, and it didn't properly report a March 2023 data breach.

A parallel privacy inquiry abroad is covered in the FTC's ChatGPT privacy probe.

The data breach was significant. A bug in ChatGPT's system briefly allowed some users to see other users' chat histories and payment information. OpenAI disclosed the breach but, according to the Garante, didn't notify the Italian authority within the 72-hour window required by GDPR Article 33.

Italy's ban made global headlines. ChatGPT went dark for Italian users for approximately one month. OpenAI responded by implementing age verification gates, updating its privacy policy for European users, and providing options for users to opt out of having their data used for training. The service was reinstated, but the Garante's investigation continued.

Garante per la Protezione dei Dati Personali v. OpenAI (Italian DPA v. OpenAI)
Garante Decision (Dec. 2024); original ban order March 30, 2023
Court
Italian Data Protection Authority (Garante)
Date
2024-12-20
Category
AI Privacy / Confidentiality
Sanctions
EUR 15,000,000 (~$16.5 million USD)
AI Case Law: Updated November 2026

What Happened

The Garante spent over a year investigating OpenAI's data practices before reaching its conclusion. The authority examined how OpenAI collected training data, how it handled user interactions, what personal data was processed, and whether users had adequate control over their information.

In December 2024, the Garante imposed a EUR 15 million fine, announced together with a six-month information campaign. The fine addressed the original violations: processing personal data without a lawful basis, inadequate age verification, and the data breach notification failure. The Garante also ordered OpenAI to conduct a six-month public awareness campaign in Italy about how ChatGPT processes personal data.

OpenAI called the fine 'disproportionate' and appealed. The company argued it had addressed the Garante's concerns promptly and implemented substantial privacy protections for European users. Update, October 28, 2026: the appeal succeeded. According to the Garante's own page on the case (read October 28, 2026), Tribunal of Rome judgment No. 4153/2026, published March 18, 2026, accepted OpenAI's appeal against decision No. 755, and the Garante has temporarily removed that decision from its website. The fine and the campaign order therefore no longer stand as issued. We have not read the judgment itself, so we do not state its grounds; the Garante's page does not say whether the court reached the merits.


The Ruling

The Garante's December 2024 decision rested on three core GDPR violations. First, OpenAI processed personal data included in its training corpus without a lawful basis under GDPR Article 6. The personal information of millions of Europeans was scraped from the internet and used to train models without consent, legitimate interest assessment, or any other recognized legal basis.

Second, OpenAI failed to implement effective age verification mechanisms. GDPR Article 8 requires parental consent for processing data of children under certain ages (typically 13-16, depending on the member state). ChatGPT had no meaningful barrier preventing minors from using the service and having their data processed.

Third, the March 2023 data breach notification was inadequate under GDPR Article 33's 72-hour reporting requirement. The EUR 15 million fine (~$16.5 million USD) reflected the severity and scope of the violations, though it sits below the Article 83(5) ceiling for infringements of the basic processing principles: up to EUR 20 million or, for an undertaking, up to 4% of total worldwide annual turnover of the preceding financial year, whichever is higher (Regulation (EU) 2016/679, read November 1, 2026 in the gdpr-info.eu copy of the text). Breaches of the controller and processor obligations in Articles 25 to 39, which include breach notification, carry the separate Article 83(4) ceiling of EUR 10 million or 2%.

Outcome: The Garante imposed a EUR 15 million fine in December 2024. OpenAI was also ordered to conduct a six-month public awareness campaign about how ChatGPT processes personal data. OpenAI called the fine 'disproportionate' and appealed; the Tribunal of Rome accepted the appeal on March 18, 2026 (judgment No. 4153/2026, per the Garante's page).

Why This Case Matters

This case set the regulatory template for AI in Europe. After Italy acted, data protection authorities in France, Germany, Spain, Poland, and other EU member states launched their own investigations into generative AI companies. The Garante proved that existing privacy law (GDPR) applies to AI companies, and other regulators followed.

Another legal front against OpenAI is explained in Walters v. OpenAI and defamation by AI hallucination, where the complaint concerns a ChatGPT hallucination.

The EUR 15 million fine is below the Article 83(5) ceiling, which is at least EUR 20 million, but the precedent is what matters. The Garante established that scraping personal data from the internet to train AI models requires a lawful basis under GDPR. That's a fundamental challenge to how every large language model is built, since they all train on internet data containing personal information.

For U.S. law firms with European clients or operations, this case is a compliance warning. Any AI tool that processes personal data of EU residents must comply with GDPR. That includes not just AI companies themselves but also law firms using AI tools with client data that touches European individuals. The chain of GDPR compliance doesn't stop at the AI provider. A practical exposure checklist for U.S. firms: (1) identify which AI tools receive documents containing EU personal data; (2) confirm each vendor has a valid DPA and Data Processing Agreement under GDPR Article 28; (3) verify the tool's lawful basis under GDPR Article 13: the transparency obligation requires vendors to disclose what data is processed and why; and (4) check whether your firm qualifies as a data controller (not just a processor) under GDPR, which carries direct liability.


Lessons for Attorneys

Attorneys advising AI companies need to map their GDPR exposure now. If your client's AI product is available to EU users or trains on data containing EU residents' personal information, the Italian DPA ruling creates direct compliance obligations. Lawful basis for data processing, age verification, data breach notification procedures, and user opt-out mechanisms are all mandatory.

For firms with European offices or clients: review which AI tools your attorneys use and whether those tools comply with GDPR. If an attorney uploads a document containing a European client's personal data to a consumer AI tool, that processing needs a lawful basis. The firm, not just the AI provider, bears GDPR responsibility as a data controller.

For managing partners watching the regulatory landscape: European AI regulation is moving faster than U.S. regulation. The EU AI Act is layering additional requirements on top of GDPR. Firms that develop GDPR and AI Act compliance expertise now will capture advisory work as every AI company selling into Europe needs legal guidance. This is a growing practice area, not a one-time regulatory event.


The Bottom Line

Italy's EUR 15 million GDPR fine against OpenAI was an early regulatory penalty targeting generative AI (since set aside by a Rome court) and pushed every AI company operating in Europe to reassess data practices. Attorneys advising companies with EU exposure need to treat AI compliance as a core GDPR obligation, not an afterthought.

AI-Assisted Research. This piece was researched and written with AI assistance, reviewed and edited by Manu Ayala. For deeper takes and the perspective behind the research, follow me on LinkedIn or email me directly.

Price sources, checked 22 October 2026: Gavel. Each figure above is a list price from the vendor's own pricing page, or arithmetic on one. Plans, seat minimums and promotions change; confirm on the vendor's page before you buy.