Direct answer · as of October 24, 2026
Andersen v. Stability AI (N.D. Cal. No. 3:23-cv-00201-WHO) is a class action by visual artists against Stability AI, Midjourney and DeviantArt over training image generators on copyrighted artworks. It is still in discovery, with expert reports due from December 8, 2026 and no trial date set. Source: the case docket on CourtListener, orders read in their PDFs on October 24, 2026.
Three visual artists sued Stability AI, Midjourney, and DeviantArt in a class action alleging AI image generators were trained on billions of copyrighted artworks without permission. This is the case that will decide whether AI art generation constitutes copyright infringement, and as of October 24, 2026 it is still in discovery, with expert reports due from December 8, 2026 and no trial date set.
Procedural status as of October 24, 2026
Source: the docket for N.D. Cal. No. 3:23-cv-00201-WHO on CourtListener, with each order below read in its RECAP PDF on October 24, 2026 (ECF 774 is a text-only order read in the CourtListener index). The parties in the caption of ECF 623 are eight plaintiffs (Sarah Andersen, Karla Ortiz, Grzegorz Rutkowski, Gregory Manchess, Gerald Brom, Jingna Zhang, Julia Kaye and Adam Ellis) against Stability AI Ltd., Stability AI, Inc., Midjourney, DeviantArt and Runway AI.
Getty Images' separate UK case against the same defendant is tracked in Getty Images v. Stability AI in the UK.
- April 21, 2026, ECF 499: Judge Orrick extended the discovery cutoff to July 1, 2026 and the deposition cutoff to August 15, 2026, and wrote that he did not expect to grant further extensions.
- July 1, 2026, ECF 623: a stipulated order by Magistrate Judge Cisneros moved the deadline for final responses to contention interrogatories to August 17, 2026.
- September 23, 2026, ECF 759: the plaintiffs moved to extend the expert schedule by 60 days, citing late production of Midjourney art and artist datasets and the structure of Stability AI's datasets.
- September 28, 2026, ECF 764: Judge Orrick granted that motion and set the following schedule. Opening expert reports December 8, 2026; responsive reports January 25, 2027; reply reports March 11, 2027; close of expert discovery April 12, 2027; last day to move for class certification and summary judgment June 17, 2027; oppositions July 29, 2027; replies September 3, 2027; hearing September 29, 2027. The pretrial conference and the trial are "to be set by Court", so no trial date exists in that order.
- October 6, 2026, ECF 774: Judge Orrick denied a stipulation (ECF 773) asking for more time to finish contention-interrogatory discovery and file joint letters.
- October 19, 2026, ECF 778: Judge Cisneros approved a stipulation in which the plaintiffs withdrew their motion for discovery sanctions against DeviantArt (ECF 730) and the October 20 hearing was vacated.
What is not established: any ruling on fair use or on the merits, any class certification decision, and any trial date. The entries above are scheduling and discovery orders.
Background
Sarah Andersen, Kelly McKernan, and Karla Ortiz are professional visual artists whose work was scraped from the internet and included in the LAION-5B dataset, a massive collection of image-text pairs used to train AI image generators. Stability AI used LAION-5B to train Stable Diffusion, its open-source image generation model. Midjourney and DeviantArt built products on top of similar technology.
The artists filed their class action in the Northern District of California on January 13, 2023, under Case No. 3:23-cv-00201. They alleged that the AI companies copied billions of copyrighted images to train their models, and that the resulting AI tools can generate images 'in the style of' specific artists, effectively competing with the originals. The original complaint included claims under DMCA Section 1202 for removal of copyright management information; the court dismissed them with prejudice in August 2024. Getty Images v. Stability AI is a related suit against the same defendant; its English High Court judgment is covered on our UK page.
The case was assigned to Judge William Orrick. It quickly became the leading test case for whether generative AI image tools violate artists' copyrights, drawing attention from the art community, AI industry, and intellectual property bar.
What Happened
The defendants moved to dismiss, arguing that AI training is transformative fair use and that AI-generated images are new works, not copies. Judge Orrick initially dismissed most claims in October 2023 but allowed the direct copyright infringement claim against Stability AI to proceed. The key reasoning: training the model involved making actual copies of copyrighted images, and that copying alone can constitute infringement.
The plaintiffs filed an amended complaint addressing the court's concerns. On August 12, 2024, Judge Orrick granted in part and denied in part the defendants' motions to dismiss the first amended complaint. The direct copyright infringement, inducement and trademark claims survived; the DMCA Section 1202 claims were dismissed with prejudice. The surviving claims gave the artists a path to discovery.
The case is now in discovery, which is the real battleground. Discovery has given the artists access to training data logs, internal communications about copyright concerns, and technical details about how specific copyrighted images influenced model outputs. That evidence will shape not just this case but the entire AI art copyright debate.
The Ruling
Judge Orrick's rulings addressed a core question: does copying images to train an AI model count as copyright infringement? For Stability AI, the answer was that the claim survived because training Stable Diffusion required making copies of copyrighted works. That's a straightforward act of reproduction, regardless of whether the AI outputs are themselves infringing.
The August 12, 2024 ruling let the direct infringement, inducement and trademark claims go forward and dismissed the DMCA Section 1202 claims with prejudice (Copyright Alliance, read 2026-10-29). We have not re-read the order itself, so we do not restate its reasoning on Midjourney's training copies or on derivative works.
The court hasn't ruled on the merits yet. Fair use will be the central defense, and it requires factual development. But the fact that the case survived two rounds of motions to dismiss means the court sees viable copyright claims in AI training on copyrighted images.
Outcome: Judge Orrick initially dismissed most claims in October 2023 but allowed the direct copyright infringement claim against Stability AI to proceed. On August 12, 2024, the court granted in part and denied in part the motions to dismiss the first amended complaint, advancing the surviving claims toward discovery, where it remains as of October 24, 2026.
Why This Case Matters
Andersen v. Stability AI is doing for visual art what NYT v. OpenAI is doing for text. Together, they'll define whether AI companies need permission to train on copyrighted content. The difference here is the visual medium: artists can show, side by side, their original work and AI-generated images 'in their style.' That visual comparison is powerful evidence.
The discovery phase is groundbreaking. For the first time, a court will force AI companies to reveal exactly how their training datasets were constructed, what role specific copyrighted works played, and whether internal teams knew they were building products on unlicensed content. That factual record doesn't just matter for this case. It becomes the foundation for every AI copyright case that follows.
For the broader creative industry, this case is existential. If AI companies can train on any publicly available image without permission, artists lose control over how their work is used. If they can't, the entire generative AI art industry needs to be rebuilt on licensed datasets. There's no middle ground.
Lessons for Attorneys
Attorneys representing creative professionals should be preparing clients for the discovery outcomes. The evidence that emerges from this case will directly inform whether artists, photographers, and designers have viable claims against AI companies. Start documenting clients' copyrighted works now, including registration status, because statutory damages require timely registration.
Firms advising AI companies need to audit their training data pipelines. This case makes clear that 'we scraped it from the internet' isn't a legal defense. If the training data includes copyrighted works, the company needs a fair use argument or a license. The safest path is building toward licensed or permissioned datasets before the courts force the issue.
For IP practices generally, this case is a preview of the next decade of copyright litigation. Every industry that produces copyrighted content (publishing, music, photography, software) faces the same question. The firms that develop expertise in AI training data copyright now will own the space when these cases multiply.
The Bottom Line
Andersen v. Stability AI is the leading case testing whether AI image generation violates artists' copyrights. Key claims survived dismissal, and discovery is exposing how AI training datasets are built. Every attorney in IP practice needs to understand this case because it's writing the rules for AI and creative rights.
AI-Assisted Research. This piece was researched and written with AI assistance, reviewed and edited by Manu Ayala. For deeper takes and the perspective behind the research, follow me on LinkedIn or email me directly.
Price sources, checked 22 October 2026: Gavel. Each figure above is a list price from the vendor's own pricing page, or arithmetic on one. Plans, seat minimums and promotions change; confirm on the vendor's page before you buy.